Second blog ever
In an article for the New York Times titled ”Teach Your Teachers Well” (http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/02/opinion/02engel.html?_r=1&em), Susan Engel claims that ”These new teacher programs should be selective, requiring a 3.5 undergraduate grade point average and an intensive application process”. In other words, Universities need to tighten their criteria as to who is accepted into the credential programs also known as Teacher’s College here in Canada. One of these criteria would be to accept candidates with a 3.5 GPA or higher.
Although students with a high GPA can make excellent teachers, I believe that students with a lower score have equal chances of becoming exceptional teachers.
A student’s GPA is a very weak indicator about someone’s intelligence. A teacher needs to reach out to all her students, meaning he or she must use teaching strategies that will engage and motivate the visual, auditive, mathematical, literal and analytical student. Many university professors will present their lectures in a magisterial manner, which engages very few students. Does this mean that students having a harder time understanding learning concepts in this fashion will not make good teachers? I think not. Teachers in elementary and high school need to focus on developing skills just as much as knowledge for their students. It does not take a perfect GPA to excel at these tasks.
Other qualities that make a good teacher, that are irrelevant to someone’s GPA, are eloquent speakers (maybe not as eloquent as Obama but you know what I mean), patience, motivation and a really good sense of humor, which I think I have but need to develop more the last one.
There is a huge lack of exceptional teachers. Why limit potential candidates based solely on the GPA.
In my opinion, past experience in teaching (paid or volunteer) needs to be more of an important prerequisite. If past references are proof of the candidate’s teaching abilities and motivation, then these individuals will be more likely to become excellent teachers.
I wonder if anyone has done any studies about the correlation between a teacher’s GPA and their performance. Maybe it would be an interesting doctorate thesis. Oh and what is up with professors that teach in various Faculties of Education and have never actually taught in a real classroom. But I digress. This subject will be blogged for another time.